| "The Million Dollar Man" Ted DiBiase | In "Randy Orton's RTWM", beat Ted DiBiase Jr. at Wrestlemania and KO "The Million Dollar Man" after the match |
| Alternate Attire for Chris Jericho | Week 6 of "HBK's RTWM", Make Jericho Bleed |
| Alternate Attire for Edge | Week 6 of "Edge's RTWM", Win in under 3 minutes |
| Alternate Attire for JBL | Week 8 of "HBK's RTWM", Win the match in under 4 minutes |
| Alternate Attire for Mickie James | Week 6 of "Mickie James' RTWM", beat Michelle McCool in under 3 minutes |
| Alternate Attire for Mr. Kennedy | In "Edge's RTWM", eliminate Mr. Kennedy from the Royal Rumble Match |
| Alternate attire for Mr. McMahon (suit) | Week 5 of "Create-A-Superstar's RTWM", Spend at least one minute of the match outside the ring |
| Alternate Attire for Natalya | Week 9 of "Mickie James' RTWM", Choose Kendrick over Natalya. Then at week 10, win the match suffering minimal damage |
| Alternate Attire for Santino Marella (Street clothes) | Week 12 of "Create-A-Superstar's RTWM", make a successful diving attack from the top of the ladder |
| Alternate Attire for Shawn Michaels | Week 4 of "HBK's RTWM", hit both opponents with Sweet CHIN Music |
| Alternate Attire for Shawn Michaels (DX) (Option 1) | Week 10 of "HBK's RTWM", Accept the Retirement Match, then at Week 11, have your partner be the legal man longer |
| Alternate Attire for Shawn Michaels (DX) (Option 2) | Week 10 of "HBK's RTWM", Decline the Retirement Match, then at Week 11, Execute 3 Double Team attacks |
| Alternate Attire for The Brian Kendrick | Week 9 of 'Mickie James' RTWM", choose Natalya over Kendrick. Then at week 12, win the match without using a signature move or finisher |
| Alternate Attire for Vince McMahon (Chicken Head) | Win the WrestleMania Match in "Create-A-Superstar's RTWM" |
| Alternate Attires for Miz and Morrison (Street clothes) & Dirt Sheet area for Backstage Brawl | Week 11 of "Brand Warfare's RTWM", win the handicap match as either Triple H or John Cena |
| Champion of Champions title belt | Win at Wrestlemania in "Brand Warfare's RTWM" |
| Cowboy Bob Orton | Week 9 of "Randy Orton's RTWM", dont use any strikes in your match |
| Dusty Rhodes | In "Randy Orton's RTWM", beat Cody Rhodes at WrestleMania and KO Dusty after the match |
| Eve | Week 2 of "Mickie James' RTWM", pin or submit Maryse |
| Ezekiel Jackson | Week 3 of "Create-A-Superstar's RTWM", throw each opponent out of the ring at least once. |
| Green and Red Dummies as Playable Characters | Week 3 of "Randy Orton's RTWM", refuse Codys help and then reverse three of Batista's attacks. |
| Interview Room for Backstage | Complete Shawn Michaels RTW |
| Jesse | Week 2 of "Edge's RTWM", hit every opponent with a finisher |
| John Cena Alternate Attire (Street Clothes) | Week 4 of "Brand Warfare's RTWM", you must put Kane through a table in less than 2:30 as John Cena. |
| Locker Room Backstage area | In "Edge's RTWM", at No Way Out, drag Mr. Kennedy on top of the Big Show and count the pinfall |
| Mr. McMahon (Playable Character) | Week 11 of "Edge's RTWM", Put Triple H through an announce table |
| Randy Ortons Alternate Attire | In "Randy Orton's RTWM", at No Way Out, RKO Dusty Rhodes |
| Road to Wrestlemania Event Skip Feature | Week 12 of "Randy Orton's RTWM", Spend less than 2 minutes in the ring as the legal superstar |
| Santino Marella Story Designer story | Week 11 of "Create-A-Superstar's RTWM", reach 500 degrees at least four times |
| The Hardys, DX, & Morrison and The Miz Tag Entrances | Week 2 of "Brand Warfare's RTWM", you must win the battle royal as either Triple H or John Cena |
| The Rock | Complete Edge's Road to Wrestlemania |
| Triple H Alternate Attire (DX) | Week 6 of "Brand Warfare's RTWM", win your match in under 3 minutes as Triple H. |
| Trish Stratus | Complete Mickies Road to Wrestlemania |
| Vinces Office in Backstage Brawl | Week 6 of "Create-A-Superstar's RTWM", win your match |
